1. Quotes
  2. Authors
  3. John Carroll

John Carroll Quotes

John Carroll is Emeritus Professor of Sociology at La Trobe University in Melbourne Australia. He is the author of Puritan, Paranoid, Remissive, Guilt, Ego and Soul, Humanism: The Rebirth and Wreck of Western Culture, and Intruders In The Bush: The Australian Quest For Identity. His Cambridge doctoral dissertation on epistemological anarchistic and anti-rationalist themes in Max Stirner, Nietzsche and Dostoyevsky was published as Breakout from the Crystal Palace . It was supervised by George Steiner. Puritan, Paranoid, Remissive echoed and developed upon themes in Philip Rieff's Triumph of the Therapeutic: Uses of Faith after Freud .

Humanism is Carroll's most ambitious work to date. Predicated on the view that Western high culture is in a declining if not nihilistic mode, Humanism traces this decline to an epistemic tyranny of reason and its subjection of other forms of knowing and understanding being. Carroll's often bleak diagnosis is primarily based on unique readings of canonic theological, philosophical and artistic texts including those by Sophocles, Calvin, Holbein, Donatello, Shakespeare, Rembrandt, Poussin, Henry James and John Ford. The heart of the book's analysis is highly indebted to Nietzsche's critique of "Socratic" culture in The Birth of Tragedy. Terror: a Meditation on the Meaning of September 11 is an application of many of the themes in the former work.

In The Western Dreaming and The Existential Jesus, Carroll rereads Gospel narratives and the ontology of Christ through a Heideggerian and non-theistic lens. His most recent work, Greek Pilgrimage, is an unabashed hellenophilic meditation on the nature of ancient Greek aesthetics and culture and what remains of the archaeological sites themselves. His forthcoming book, Land of the Golden Cities, is expected to be published late in 2016.

✵ 1944
John Carroll: 58   quotes 0   likes

Famous John Carroll Quotes

“Utilitarianism had found [ in Samuel Smiles’ Self-Help] its portrait gallery of heroes, inscribed with a vigorous exhortation to all men to strive in their image; this philistine romanticism established the bourgeois hero-prototype—the penniless office-boy who works his way to economic fortune and this wins his way into the mercantile plutocracy.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 12

“The attachment to a rationalistic, teleological notion of progress indicates the absence of true progress; he whose life does not unfold satisfyingly under its own momentum is driven to moralize it, to set up goals and rationalize their achievement as progress.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 34

“Man is more than an animal only in that he finds expression for the beautiful.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 92

“Men become utilitarian out of fear of the alternative—the chaos of tangled or tepid desires, of rootlessness and boredom.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 148

“… the bourgeois, who is not a real owner, but the servant of his avarice”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 62

“The dialectical critique of positivist habits of mind … is interested only in behaviour which is ‘important’ to the actor; that is, behaviour which is emotionally charged to the degree that it is either frequently recalled, reflected upon, or day-dreamed about. … That science which is less discriminating in the behaviour it chooses to investigate gains clarity and distinctiveness at the cost of confining itself to the trivial.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 168

John Carroll Quotes about life

“The real task is not to rid life of ethics but to rid ethics of its ideological content.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 38

“Modern anthropology … opposes the utilitarian assumption that the primitive chants as he sows seed because he believes that otherwise it will not grow, the assumption that his economic goal is primary, and his other activities are instrumental to it. The planting and the cultivating are no less important than the finished product. Life is not conceived as a linear progression directed to, and justified by, the achievement of a series of goals; it is a cycle in which ends cannot be isolated, one which cannot be dissected into a series of ends and means.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), pp. 150-151

“Any attempt to break with the past, or with existing social structures, is a failure if it leads to a bored, listless, and colourless style of life; assertive and enduring innovation, like the mastering of a new environment, requires the confidence and discipline which are founded on exuberant emotions.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), pp. 95-96, note

“Nietzsche … combines, in effect, Christ’s harsh sayings: ‘let the dead bury their dead’ and ‘narrow is the way which leadeth unto life’.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 98

“Nietzsche … argues that all that passes in the life of a society is ephemeral and banausic except for the presence of great personalities, of men like Goethe … who seem to forge their own destinies, who seem to move unhampered by those burdens of existence which keep most men from rising above the vicissitudes of their daily toil.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 93

“Life is more than thought: what a man feels, and what his senses awaken in him, are more indispensable to his life’s fullness than subsequent reflection on their significance. Both Stirner and Nietzsche have elaborated Faust’s opening speech in which he bemoans his wasted years in academia: this speech is Goethe’s own impeachment of Kant and Hegel. Philosophy proceeds always under the risk of making a fetish of thinking.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 105

John Carroll: Trending quotes

“The act of greatest subversion … is the one of indifference.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 53
Context: The act of greatest subversion … is the one of indifference. A man, or a group, finds it unbearable that someone can be simply uninterested in his, or its, convictions. … There is a degree of complicity, or mutual respect, between the believer and the man who attacks his beliefs (the revolutionary), for the latter takes them seriously.

Indifference

“Nietzsche [claims] that the scientist is at best an instrument, a useful slave: he does not command or decide, he is not a whole man.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 111

“The garden [of Eden] is the realm of pure beauty from which man is expelled when he becomes interested in ethics, in the fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil. The return into paradise, the homecoming, depends on him penetrating the veils of morality to glimpse again the lineaments of lost beauty.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 92

Beauty , Knowledge , Tree , Evil

John Carroll Quotes

“Whereas Marx’s vision of homo faber becomes inoperative within social chains, Stirner’s man makes his own freedom.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 79

Freedom

“Ownership of thought depends on the thinker not subordinating himself to a ‘ruling thought’. This is particularly difficult, argues Stirner, … for language itself is a network of ‘fixed ideas’. Truths emerge only when language is reworked and possessed individually.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 107

Truth , Idea , Dependency

“Stirner and Nietzsche [adopt] a mode of thinking which is personal, introspective, and which while often operating on alternative systems of belief and action does so only as a means of better grasping one dominant goal—the patterns of individual redemption. Stirner and Nietzsche are not primarily interested in critique as such. … Their work is too egoistically compelled for them ever to employ the external world as more than the repository for a series of projections of their own.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 174

World , Thinking , Personality

“Nietzsche … criticizes Schopenhauerian aesthetics for not freeing itself from Kant’s moralistic: ‘that is beautiful which gives us pleasure without interest’.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 95

Pleasure , Beauty

“What stands most explicitly as critique in Nietzsche’s late work in not a development from earlier interests but a return to two problems of enduring personal involvement for him, those of Wagner and of Christianity. Der Antichrist, to take one case, is not a response to a resuscitating public interest in Christian religion; it is primarily a renewed attempt to resolve for himself the question of piety.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 174

Religion , Question , Problem , Personality

“The virtual suppression of ethical discussion after 1845 produces the semblance of purely descriptive analysis, dressed in the mantle of positivist objectivity, analysis which is, in fact, strung to a framework of crude, because unexplicated, moral assumptions.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 80

“In so far as the intention of education is to train the child for a vocation it is a millstone around his neck.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 34

Education , Training

“The Inquisitor is the forgiving father, the scientific materialist, and the social engineer. He is the most compassionate, and honest, of politicians; he takes on great burdens of responsibility in order to protect his subjects from ethical doubt. But he also suppresses any attempt to expand their self-consciousness: he is the ‘great simplifier’, the shepherd to a flock of carefree children.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 153

Children , Forgiveness

“Unlike Hegel’s progress model of history, which moves by stages, each containing its own logic of growth and decline, the economic model develops as the simple function of one money-variable over time, with a long-term trend which increases monotonically.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 168

Money , History , Time

“The priest who has lost the resilience of youth cannot be helped; his polymorphously playful and imaginative energies have been emasculated by a long conditioning to the ways of the old order; he would be liberated into a sea of undifferentiated boredom and anxiety. Only the man whose desires and passions are intact has a future.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 95

Youth , Way , Imagination , Passion

“Nietzsche saw in the Protestant ethic, in both its religious and secular (economic) forms, a final protest before the emergence into dominance of the ordered, bourgeois world of the ‘last man’—he who will pay any price in tedium for comfort and the absence of tension.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 96

World

“Stirner … holds to a joy-principle rather than to a pleasure-principle.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 143

Pleasure , Joy

“The original of morals lies with the thought that ‘the community is more valuable than the individual”

John Carroll

Menschliches 2.1.89
Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 80, note

Communication

“Dostoevsky … impeaches Christ through the mouth of the Grand Inquisitor: ‘it was pitiless of thee to value man so highly’. This Christ has no answer to the world of politics, of rational action, of knowledge. He is utterly Nietzschean in his intention not to pity, but to respect.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 154

World , Knowledge , Christ

“Nietzsche himself was a great moralist; his writings abound with value judgments about individuals, character types, modes of thinking, and national traits. It is as if he develops immoralist psychology in order to tame his own nature, to keep his own greatest vice in check.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 38

Nature , Thinking

“Nietzsche … explicates his preferred distinction between good and bad individuals as non-condemnatory of the latter. A ‘bad person’ is merely devoid of what Nietzsche personally considers to be noble or virtuous qualities; he is not morally evil. Nietzsche’s aim is … to defuse morality of reactive emotion. … It would be futile, tactless, and cruel, he suggests, to try to change a bad person, one with whom one does not empathize; his formula advises: ‘Where you cannot love, pass by’. No on should be blamed for what he is; there is no point in lamenting fate.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 91

Love , Fate , Evil , Change

“Dostoevsky believed that the gods of rationalism and materialist utilitarianism had joined in conspiracy against all other ethical systems. … The accumulation of capital, or the acquisition of money, are endeavors par excellence which establish a quantifiable goal: hence they are directly amenable to maximization formulae.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 149

Money , God

“The possibility of a genuine metatheory of morality is not available. Even psychology has its ethical presuppositions. … A metatheory of morality would be legitimate only if the existence of a hierarchy of absolute, and hence unconditioned, truths were established. They would then provide a framework of supra-ethical categories. The primary ambition of Nietzsche’s critique of knowledge is to expose just such an exercise … as sleight of hand, an efficacious deception. This critique sets out to demonstrate that ‘truths’ are fictions masking moral commitments”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 102

Truth , Exercises , Knowledge

“This will of Stirner’s, this restless probing of all given knowledge, this endless questioning, and the continuous bending towards new understanding, …”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 107

Understanding , Question , Knowledge

“Stirner’s political praxis is quixotic. It accepts the established hierarchies of constraint as given. … Not liable to any radical change, they constitute part of the theatre housing the individual’s action. … The egoist uses the elements of the social structure as props in his self-expressive act.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 85

Change , Parting , Housing

“For Stirner, the social axiom of conservative, liberal, and socialist schools of political thought alike is in itself repressive: it disguises as potentially redemptive an order whose central function is inhibitory of the individual’s interests.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 55

School

“There is a strong strain of Protestant masochism in this [Nietzsche’s] assault on morality and ideology. … Framing this perspective is the Protest image of the utterly self-reliant, responsible individual.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 39

Strong

“R. W. K. Paterson makes a central point of identifying Stirner with nihilism. His argument depends on a failure to distinguish between social values, which Stirner does reject, and personal values, to which he is more overtly committed than any other philosopher.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 108, note

Failure , Dependency , Personality

“The enemies of Christ … could not bear his independence; his “Give the emperor that which is the emperor’s” showed a contempt for the affairs of state and its politics—for the moral order—that their self-respect would not let them tolerate.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 53

Christ

“Education is the strongest weapon available for restricting the questions people ask, controlling what they think, and ensuring that they get their thoughts ‘from above’.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 34

People , Education , Question , Thinking

“If man is to remain the creator and master of his world then, Stirner maintains, … all that has been accepted, that has taken on the secure guise of the ‘fact’, must be return to a state of flux, or be rejected.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 107

World

“Politics and the affairs of State are dissociated from the orbit of the individual, and in so far as they cannot be repossessed as his living private property they must be rendered impotent.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 54

“Copernicus and Darwin undermined man’s image of himself as the ‘measure of all things’. Newton provided him with a new hope … that of ‘man as the measurer of all things’. Thus the possibility was revealed to man, who had been disinherited from being at the center of the universe, that he might be able know how to work himself back there. Science, at the same time it destroyed his ontological security, gave him the tools for reapproaching Eden.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 97

Hope , Universe , Science , Time

“The estranged ego projects its own disorder on to society and expects the restructuring and integration of the self writ large, the society, to reflect back on to the source of consciousness. Stirner regards this flight from self as a form of suicide, the dissolution of identity and uniqueness.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 79

Suicide

“Man at his best is a system-breaker, an iconoclast seeking not only variety, but destruction.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 152

“The ‘I think, therefore I am’ of Descartes, the ‘I feel, therefore I am’ of late eighteenth century Romanticism, and the ‘I possess therefore I am’ of bourgeois man are dogmas, partial at that, incorporated to define a being that is incapable of defining itself.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 40

Feeling , Thinking

“There is a strain in Marx of the cleric, of the vulgar moralist. He paints the capitalist and the bourgeois as incarnations of evil; it is they who are responsible for the woes of mankind. The dismissal of the individual’s responsibility for his own misery is the quintessence of clericalism.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 79

Evil , Painting

“A teleology directed to material ends has been substituted for the lust for adventure, variety, and play.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 148

“Stirner and Nietzsche … reveal how prone morality is to being used as a means of rationalization, a cloak for concealing violent and brutish passions, and making their sadistic expression a virtue.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 38

Passion

“The ugliness of the ideological lies in its legitimating the pursuit of the trivial.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 92

“The schizophrenic is seen to be afraid of the nihilistic void that … will remain when a rigid world-view is discarded.”

John Carroll

[describing the implications of Ehrenzweig’s theory] p. 95, note
Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974)

World

“For Dostoevsky, Fourier is one of the industrious ant-hill engineers, busy, protected by the delusion that his goal, the will-ordered society, is the summation of all his desires.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 152

Business

“By punishing the criminal the moral man hopes to dissuade the evil imprisoned in his own breast from escaping. Fear of self is projected in hatred of the immoral other.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 35

Fear , Hope , Evil

“The egoist … destroys the universal importance accorded to moral law by showing that life independent of it is possible. Secondly, and even more intolerably to the pious, he manages to do so with shameless enjoyment.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 33

Life , Law , Universe

“[ Marx] explicates ideology as socially determined, [ Stirner] as psychologically determined: both accuse it of remaining oblivious to its own determinations.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 17

“Unless the fundamental categories of economics such as ‘property’ were to be redefined in a radically personal way the liberal rationalist curse which had established economics as a scientific discipline cut off from human interests would proliferate. Economic models … have failed to incorporate any meaningful index of individual benefit other than the original utilitarian one, … the index of increasing income or an increasing flow of commodities.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 145

Way , Personality

“The primary ambition of Nietzsche’s critique of knowledge is … to demonstrate that ‘truths’ are fictions masking moral commitments.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 102

Truth , Knowledge

“Dostoevsky’s underground man … observes his contemporaries striving to establish false goals where there are no naturally generated ones. … He argues they should be conscious and honest enough to recognize that the goal itself is not an absolute, and probably not even important. A strong attachment to the telos indicates that the spontaneous enjoyment the child once took in road-building has waned.”

John Carroll

Source: Break-Out from the Crystal Palace (1974), p. 148

Nature , Strong , Falseness

Similar authors

Ronald H. Coase photo
Ronald H. Coase 19
British economist and author
Stephen R. Covey photo
Stephen R. Covey 125
American educator, author, businessman and motivational spe…
Richard Dawkins photo
Richard Dawkins 322
English ethologist, evolutionary biologist and author
John Ronald Reuel Tolkien photo
John Ronald Reuel Tolkien 78
British philologist and author, creator of classic fantasy …
Joseph E. Stiglitz photo
Joseph E. Stiglitz 39
American economist and professor, born 1943.
H.P. Lovecraft photo
H.P. Lovecraft 203
American author
Leo Buscaglia photo
Leo Buscaglia 84
Motivational speaker, writer
Friedrich Dürrenmatt photo
Friedrich Dürrenmatt 19
Swiss author and dramatist
Stephen Hawking photo
Stephen Hawking 122
British theoretical physicist, cosmologist, and author
Napoleon Hill photo
Napoleon Hill 104
American author