Quotes from book
Change the World Without Taking Power

John Holloway

Change the World Without Taking Power: The Meaning of Revolution Today is a book by John Holloway that looks at the understanding of power as the central focal point of how to effect meaningful change. Holloway uses two definitions of power, 'power-over' and 'power-to' in order to understand the difference between power from authority, power over someone else, and the power to do something, the capacity for action. Holloway argues we should never simply assume the legitimacy of anything with 'power-over' someone else and goes as far as saying this is true for the state - we should not 'fetishise' the state to the extent of simply assuming its role, responsibilities, and authority.

“There is no room for the scream in academic discourse. More than that: academic study provides us with a language and a way of thinking that makes it very difficult for us to express our scream. The scream, if it appears at all, appears as something to be explained, not as something to be articulated. The scream, from being the subject of our questions about society, becomes the object of analysis.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“We who scream exist ecstatically. We stand out beyond ourselves, we exist in two dimensions. The scream implies a tension between that which exists and that which might conceivably exist, between the indicative (that which is) and the subjunctive (that which might be).”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“Under capitalism, subjectivity can only exist antagonistically, in opposition to its own objectification. To treat the subject as already emancipated, as most mainstream theory does, is to endorse the present objectification of the subject as subjectivity, as freedom.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“It is easy to forget that the beginning is not the word, but the scream. Faced with the mutilation of human lives by capitalism, a scream of sadness, a scream of horror, a scream of anger, a scream of refusal: NO. The starting point of theoretical reflection is opposition, negativity, struggle. It is from rage that thought is born, not from the pose of reason.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“Feeling that the world is wrong does not necessarily mean that we have a picture of a utopia to put in its place. Nor does is necessarily mean a romantic, some-day-my-prince-will-come idea that, although things are wrong now, one day we shall come to a true world, a promised land, a happy ending. We need no promise of a happy ending to justify our rejection of a world we feel to be wrong.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“We do not struggle as working class, we struggle against being working class, against being classified.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“Why so negative?' says the spider to the fly. 'Be objective, forget your prejudices'. But there is no way the fly can be objective, however much she may want to be: 'to look at the web objectively, from the outside - what a dream', muses the fly, 'what an empty, deceptive dream'…. Any study of the web that does not start from the fly's entrapment in it is quite simply untrue.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“Capital acquires a dynamic of its own and the leading members of society are quite simply its most loyal servants, its most servile courtiers.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“The struggle is lost … once the logic of power becomes the logic of the revolutionary process, once the negative of refusal is converted into the positive of power-building. … If we revolt against capitalism, it is not because we want a different system of power, it is because we want a society in which power relations are dissolved. You cannot build a society of non-power relations by conquering power. Once the logic of power is adopted, the struggle against power is already lost.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“Power, for those without the means of commanding others, is frustration. The existence of power-to as power-over means that the vast majority of doers are converted into the done-to, their activity transformed into passivity, their subjectivity into objectivity.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“Capitalist power … is like one of those horrific modern bullets which do not simply pierce the flesh of the victim but explode inside her into a thousand different fragments. … The concept of fetishism is concerned with the explosion of power inside us, not as something that is distinct from the separation of doing and done (as in the concepts of 'ideology' and 'hegemony'), but as something that is integral to that separation. That separation does not just divide capitalists from workers, but explodes inside us, shaping every aspect of what we do and what we think, transforming every breath of our lives into a moment of class struggle.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“The most sensible thing seems to be to forget our negativity, to discard it as a fantasy of youth. And yet the world gets worse, the inequalities become more strident, the self-destruction of humanity seems to come closer. So perhaps we should not abandon our negativity but, on the contrary, try to theorise the world from the perspective of the scream.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“Class struggle does not take place within the constituted forms of capitalist social relations: rather the constitution of those forms is itself class struggle.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“If domination is always a process of armed robbery, the peculiarity of capitalism is that the person with the arms stands apart from the person doing the robbery, merely supervising that the robbery conforms with the law.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“The collectivity is divided into two classes of people: those who, by virtue of their ownership of the means of doing, command others to do, and those who, by virtue of the fact that they are deprived of access to the means of doing, do what the others tell them to do.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“In order to protect our jobs, our visas, our profits, our chances of receiving good grades, our sanity, we pretend not to see, we sanitise our own perception, filtering out the pain, pretending that it is not here but out there, far away, in Africa, in Russia, a hundred years ago, in an otherness that, by being alien, cleanses our own experience of all negativity.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“Struggle against capitalism must be also struggle against the 'we' who are not only against but also in capitalism. To criticise is to recognise that we are a divided self. To criticise society is to criticise our own complicity in the reproduction of that society.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“The world cannot be changed through the state. Both theoretical reflection and a whole century of bad experience tell us so.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Change the World Without Taking Power (2002)

“Our anger is directed not just against particular happenings but against a more general wrongness, a feeling that the world is askew, that the world is in some way untrue… We know that it is true, but feel that it is the truth of an untrue world.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

Source: Change the World Without Taking Power (2002), Chapter I, "The Scream"

“The stock market rises every time there is an increase in unemployment. Students are imprisoned for struggling for free education while those who are actively responsible for the misery of millions are heaped with honours and given titles of distinction: General, Secretary of Defense, President. The list goes on and on.”

John Holloway book Change the World Without Taking Power

It is impossible to read a newspaper without feeling rage, without feeling pain You can think of your own examples. Our anger changes each day, as outrage piles upon outrage.
Source: Change the World Without Taking Power (2002), Chapter I, "The Scream"

Similar authors

John Holloway photo

John Holloway 20

Mexican sociologist 1947

Frida Kahlo photo

Frida Kahlo 51

Mexican painter

Miguel Ángel Ruiz photo

Miguel Ángel Ruiz 9

Mexican writer and philosopher

Octavio Paz photo

Octavio Paz 71

Mexican writer laureated with the 1990 Nobel Prize for Lite…

Herbert A. Simon photo

Herbert A. Simon 58

American political scientist, economist, sociologist, and p…

Max Weber photo

Max Weber 41

German sociologist, philosopher, and political economist

Theodor W. Adorno photo

Theodor W. Adorno 90

German sociologist, philosopher and musicologist known for …

Tomáš Garrigue Masaryk photo

Tomáš Garrigue Masaryk 9

First Czechoslovak president

Gunnar Myrdal photo

Gunnar Myrdal 26

Swedish economist

Ludwig von Mises photo

Ludwig von Mises 62

austrian economist

Similar authors

John Holloway photo

John Holloway 20

Mexican sociologist 1947

Frida Kahlo photo

Frida Kahlo 51

Mexican painter

Miguel Ángel Ruiz photo

Miguel Ángel Ruiz 9

Mexican writer and philosopher

Octavio Paz photo

Octavio Paz 71

Mexican writer laureated with the 1990 Nobel Prize for Lite…

Herbert A. Simon photo

Herbert A. Simon 58

American political scientist, economist, sociologist, and p…