“God may not play dice with the universe, but something strange is going on with the prime numbers.”

—  Paul Erdős

Referencing Albert Einstein's famous remark that "God does not play dice with the universe", this is attributed to Erdős in "Mathematics : Homage to an Itinerant Master" by D. Mackenzie, in Science 275:759 (1997), but has also been stated to be a comment originating in a talk given by Carl Pomerance on the Erdős-Kac theorem, in San Diego in January 1997, a few months after Erdős's death. Confirmation of this by Pomerance is reported in a statement posted to the School of Engineering, Computer Science & Mathematics, University of Exeter http://empslocal.ex.ac.uk/people/staff/mrwatkin//kac-pomerance.txt, where he states it was a paraphrase of something he imagined Erdős and Mark Kac might have said, and presented in a slide-show, which subsequently became reported in a newspaper as a genuine quote of Erdős the next day. In his slide show he had them both reply to Einstein's assertion: "Maybe so, but something is going on with the primes."
Misattributed

Adopted from Wikiquote. Last update June 3, 2021. History

Help us to complete the source, original and additional information

Do you have more details about the quote "God may not play dice with the universe, but something strange is going on with the prime numbers." by Paul Erdős?
Paul Erdős photo
Paul Erdős 18
Hungarian mathematician and freelancer 1913–1996

Related quotes

Albert Einstein photo

“God does not play dice with the universe.”

Albert Einstein (1879–1955) German-born physicist and founder of the theory of relativity

Source: The Born-Einstein Letters 1916-55

Federico Fellini photo

“God may not play dice but he enjoys a good round of Trivial Pursuit every now and again.”

Federico Fellini (1920–1993) Italian filmmaker

"God"
I'm a Born Liar (2003)

Albert Einstein photo

“It seems hard to sneak a look at God's cards. But that He plays dice and uses "telepathic" methods… is something that I cannot believe for a single moment.”

Albert Einstein (1879–1955) German-born physicist and founder of the theory of relativity

Letter to Cornel Lanczos (21 March 1942), p. 68
Attributed in posthumous publications, Albert Einstein: The Human Side (1979)

Stephen Hawking photo

“So Einstein was wrong when he said, "God does not play dice." Consideration of black holes suggests, not only that God does play dice, but that he sometimes confuses us by throwing them where they can't be seen.”

Stephen Hawking book The Nature of Space and Time

During the same 1994 exchange with Penrose as the previous quote, transcribed in The Nature of Space and Time (1996) by Stephen Hawking and Roger Penrose, p. 26 http://books.google.com/books?id=LstaQTXP65cC&lpg=PA26&dq=hawking%20%22where%20they%20can't%20be%20seen%22&pg=PA26#v=onepage&q=&f=false and also in "The Nature of Space and Time" (online text) http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9409195
Unsourced variants: Not only does God play dice with the Universe; he sometimes casts them where they can't be seen.
Not only does God play dice, but... he sometimes throws them where they cannot be seen.
Variant: So Einstein was wrong when he said "God does not play dice". Consideration of black holes suggests, not only that God does play dice, but that He sometimes confuses us by throwing them where they can't be seen.

Stephen Hawking photo

“Not only does God play dice but… he sometimes throws them where they cannot be seen.”

Stephen Hawking (1942–2018) British theoretical physicist, cosmologist, and author
Ervin László photo

“In systems such as contemporary society, evolution is always a promise and devolution is always a threat. No system comes with a guarantee of ongoing evolution. The challenge is real. To ignore it is to play dice with all we have. To accept it is not to play God—it is to become an instrument of whatever divine purpose infuses the universe.”

Ervin László (1932) Hungarian musician and philosopher

Source: The systems view of the world (1996), p. 139 as cited in: Sherryl Stalinski (2005, p. 17).

Stanisław Lem photo

“Not only does God play dice with the world—He does not let us see what He has rolled.”

Stanisław Lem book Imaginary Magnitude

Imaginary Magnitude" (1981), "Lecture XLIII", tr. Marc E. Heine (1984)

“Maybe so, but something is going on with the primes.”

Carl Pomerance (1944) American mathematician

In response to Albert Einstein's (1943) quote "God doesn't play dice [with the universe]." From a 1997 lecture by Carl Pomerance on the Erdos-Kac theorem.
Due to a newspaper misprint, this quote is often misattributed to Paul Erdős. http://empslocal.ex.ac.uk/people/staff/mrwatkin/kac-pomerance.txt

“This is the universe! And I'm placing stones one by one on that. Like I'm increasing the number of stars one by one… I'm making the universe. It's like I'm a God. I'm going to become a God! On this Go Board.”

Yumi Hotta Hikaru no Go

In the anime, Hikaru says this when he plays in a Go tournament for the first time.
Hikaru no Go

Michael Gove photo

“I think that there are a number of economic factors in play. Some prices may go up. Other prices will come down.”

Michael Gove (1967) British politician

Brexit: NI retailers challenge Michael Gove on no-deal food supply https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-49545139 BBC News (1 September 2019)
2019

Related topics