“The disconcerting fact may first be pointed out that if you write badly about good writing, however profound may be your convictions or emphatic your expression of them, your style has a tiresome trick (as a wit once pointed out) of whispering: ‘Don’t listen!’ in your readers’ ears. And it is possible also to suggest that the promulgation of new-fangled aesthetic dogmas in unwieldy sentences may be accounted for—not perhaps unspitefully—by a certain deficiency in aesthetic sensibility; as being due to a lack of that delicate, unreasoned, prompt delight in all the varied and subtle manifestations in which beauty may enchant us.
Or, if the controversy is to be carried further; and if, to place it on a more modern basis, we adopt the materialistic method of interpreting aesthetic phenomena now in fashion, may we not find reason to believe that the antagonism between journalist critics and the fine writers they disapprove of is due in its ultimate analysis to what we may designate as economic causes? Are not the authors who earn their livings by their pens, and those who, by what some regard as a social injustice, have been more or less freed from this necessity—are not these two classes of authors in a sort of natural opposition to each other? He who writes at his leisure, with the desire to master his difficult art, can hardly help envying the profits of money-making authors.”

criticizing the Cambridge School of criticism, e.g. John Middleton Murry and Herbert Read, “Fine Writing,” pp. 306-307
Reperusals and Recollections (1936)

Adopted from Wikiquote. Last update June 3, 2021. History

Help us to complete the source, original and additional information

Do you have more details about the quote "The disconcerting fact may first be pointed out that if you write badly about good writing, however profound may be you…" by Logan Pearsall Smith?
Logan Pearsall Smith photo
Logan Pearsall Smith 37
British American-born writer 1865–1946

Related quotes

Quentin Crisp photo

“If at first you don’t succeed, failure may be your style.”

Quentin Crisp (1908–1999) writer, Actor

Source: The Naked Civil Servant; How To Become A Virgin; Resident Alien

Richard Bach photo
Jean Paul Sartre photo

“Ha! to forget. How childish! I feel you in my bones. Your silence screams in my ears. You may nail your mouth shut, you may cut out your tongue, can you keep yourself from existing? Will you stop your thoughts.”

Jean Paul Sartre (1905–1980) French existentialist philosopher, playwright, novelist, screenwriter, political activist, biographer, and …

Inès reiterating to Garcin that they cannot ignore one another, Act 1, sc. 5
No Exit (1944)
Source: No Exit and Three Other Plays

Benedict of Nursia photo
Bill Hybels photo
Conor Oberst photo
Isaac Watts photo

“I write not for your farthing, but to try / How I your farthing writers, may outvie.”

Isaac Watts (1674–1748) English hymnwriter, theologian and logician

An early couplet,quoted in Christian Hymn Writers,(ed Elsie Houghton) Evangelical Press of Wales, Bridgend,Wales 1982 ISBN 0 900898 66 6.
Attributed from postum publications, Hymns and Spiritual Songs (1773)

Edward G. Robinson photo

“The first symptom is that hair grows on your ears. It's very disconcerting.”

Edward G. Robinson (1893–1973) Romanian American actor

On growing old; op. cit.

Maya Angelou photo

Related topics