Deborah Mayo Quotes

Deborah G. Mayo is an American philosopher of science and author. She is a professor emerita in the Department of Philosophy at Virginia Tech and holds a visiting appointment at the Center for the Philosophy of Natural and Social Science of the London School of Economics. Wikipedia

Deborah Mayo: 6 quotes0 likes

Famous Deborah Mayo Quotes

“Rats and mice, for example, tend spontaneously to develop a high incidence of tumors. This renders them unsuitable for detecting tumors. Still, no animals are used as often as rats and mice for assessing the effect of numerous experimental treatments upon the production of tumors. The reason is that they are inexpensive and take up little room.”

Source: Against a Scientific Justification of Animal Experiments, p. 355

“Arguments to the effect that it is wrong to cause pain and suffering to animals are often rejected by claiming that animals simply do not suffer. … Ironically, it is precisely upon the assumption that animals do suffer from stress, fear, and pain in a manner similar to humans that the validity of much of animal experimentation rests. Few, if any, conditions are studied as widely in animals as are pain, stress, ulcers, fear, and anxiety.”

Source: Against a Scientific Justification of Animal Experiments, pp. 345-346

“Those experiments that cannot be justified on scientific grounds can be no more justified than the frivolous killing and torturing of animals. In fact they are even less capable of justification, since such experiments block more fruitful uses of scientific resources.”

Source: Against a Scientific Justification of Animal Experiments, p. 340

“The error in depicting critics of animal experiments as anti-science becomes clear when one begins to question the extent to which the purported scientific aims of these experiments are actually accomplished. For then it turns out that the experiments and not their critics are unscientific.”

Source: Against a Scientific Justification of Animal Experiments, p. 340

“Interspecies differences may lead to concluding that substances that are innocuous or beneficial in humans are harmful, and that substances that have insidious effects on humans are harmless. For example, penicillin is extremely poisonous to guinea pigs. Had penicillin been subjected to the routine animal tests, as new drugs presently are, it would never have been tried on humans.”

Source: Against a Scientific Justification of Animal Experiments, p. 351

“One type of medical research involves ascertaining whether certain pathological conditions in humans can be alleviated or cured by certain drugs. Animals are used as "models" upon which to test these treatments. To do this it is necessary for the animal subject to have the condition in question, and in order to bring this about healthy animals are made sick. … It turns out, however, that the conditions artificially induced have little in common with the naturally occurring diseases in animals (when these exist) and much less in common with the diseases in man.”

Source: Against a Scientific Justification of Animal Experiments, pp. 343-344

Similar authors

Ayn Rand322

Russian-American novelist and philosopher None

William James photo

William James246

American philosopher, psychologist, and pragmatist None

Martin Heidegger photo

Martin Heidegger69

German philosopher None

Claude Adrien Helvétius photo

Claude Adrien Helvétius8

French philosopher None

Baruch Spinoza photo

Baruch Spinoza210

Dutch philosopher None

Henri-Frédéric Amiel photo

Henri-Frédéric Amiel50

Swiss philosopher and poet None

Paulo Freire photo

Paulo Freire115

educator and philosopher None

Arthur Schopenhauer photo

Arthur Schopenhauer261

German philosopher None

Immanuel Kant photo

Immanuel Kant200

German philosopher None

Antisthenes photo

Antisthenes24

Greek philosopher None