“We are at heart so profoundly anarchistic that the only form of state we can imagine living in is Utopian; and so cynical that the only Utopia we can believe in is authoritarian.”

Notebook entry (1948), published in Partisan Review: 50th Anniversary Edition, ed. William Philips (1985)

Adopted from Wikiquote. Last update June 3, 2021. History

Help us to complete the source, original and additional information

Do you have more details about the quote "We are at heart so profoundly anarchistic that the only form of state we can imagine living in is Utopian; and so cynic…" by Lionel Trilling?
Lionel Trilling photo
Lionel Trilling 30
American academic 1905–1975

Related quotes

“We can only learn so much and live.”

Source: Hannibal

James Anthony Froude photo
Bob Black photo

“We need anarchists unencumbered by anarchism. Then, and only then, we can begin to get serious about fomenting anarchy.”

Bob Black (1951) American anarchist

Anarchism And Other Impediments To Anarchy (1985)
Context: Every organization has more in common with every other organization than it does with any of the unorganized. The anarchist critique of the state, if only the anarchists understood it, is but a special case of the critique of organization. And, at some level, even anarchist organizations sense this.
Anti-anarchists may well conclude that if there is to be hierarchy and coercion, let it be out in the open, clearly labeled as such. Unlike these pundits (the right-wing "libertarians", the minarchists, for instance) I stubbornly persist in my opposition to the state. But not because, as anarchists so often thoughtlessly declaim, the state is not "necessary". Ordinary people dismiss this anarchist assertion as ludicrous, and so they should. Obviously, in an industrialized class society like ours, the state is necessary. The point is that the state has created the conditions in which it is indeed necessary, by stripping individuals and face-to-face voluntary associations of their powers. More fundamentally, the state's underpinnings (work, moralism, industrial technology, hierarchic organizations) are not necessary but rather antithetical to the satisfactions of real needs and desires. Unfortunately, most brands of anarchism endorse all these premises yet balk at their logical conclusion: the state.
If there were no anarchists, the state would have had to invent them. We know that on several occasions it has done just that. We need anarchists unencumbered by anarchism. Then, and only then, we can begin to get serious about fomenting anarchy.

Jane Goodall quote: “Here we are, the most clever species ever to have lived. So how is it we can destroy the only planet we have?”
Jane Goodall photo
J. B. S. Haldane photo

“The universe is not only queerer than we imagine, but queerer than we can imagine.”

J. B. S. Haldane (1892–1964) Geneticist and evolutionary biologist

Oliver Sacks, An Anthropologist on Mars (1995)
Quoted in book prefaces

Abraham Lincoln photo

“We can succeed only by concert. It is not "Can any of us imagine better?" but "Can we all do better?"”

Abraham Lincoln (1809–1865) 16th President of the United States

1860s, Second State of the Union address (1862)
Context: I do not forget the gravity which should characterize a paper addressed to the Congress of the nation by the Chief Magistrate of the nation, nor do I forget that some of you are my seniors, nor that many of you have more experience than I in the conduct of public affairs. Yet I trust that in view of the great responsibility resting upon me you will perceive no want of respect to yourselves in any undue earnestness I may seem to display. Is it doubted, then, that the plan I propose, if adopted, would shorten the war, and thus lessen its expenditure of money and of blood? Is it doubted that it would restore the national authority and national prosperity and perpetuate both indefinitely? Is it doubted that we here — Congress and Executive can secure its adoption? Will not the good people respond to a united and earnest appeal from us? Can we, can they, by any other means so certainly or so speedily assure these vital objects? We can succeed only by concert. It is not "Can any of us imagine better?" but "Can we all do better?" Object whatsoever is possible, still the question recurs, "Can we do better?"

Leon Trotsky photo

“We Marxist communists are profoundly opposed to the anarchist doctrine. This doctrine is erroneous”

Leon Trotsky (1879–1940) Marxist revolutionary from Russia

Order by the commissar for military affairs - on the murder of count Mirbach
How the Revolution Armed (1923)

Indíra Gándhí photo
Franz von Papen photo

“The hope in the hearts of millions of national socialists can be fulfilled only by an authoritarian government.”

Franz von Papen (1879–1969) German chancellor

Quoted in "Nazi conspiracy and aggression, Vol. 2" - Page 919 - 1946.
1940s

Related topics