“In the first case he is lying, and his moral character is to blame; in the second case he is ignorant or mistaken, and it is only his knowledge or his judgment which is in fault.”

The Ethics of Belief (1877), The Weight Of Authority
Context: In what cases, then, let us ask in the first place, is the testimony of a man unworthy of belief? He may say that which is untrue either knowingly or unknowingly. In the first case he is lying, and his moral character is to blame; in the second case he is ignorant or mistaken, and it is only his knowledge or his judgment which is in fault. In order that we may have the right to accept his testimony as ground for believing what he says, we must have reasonable grounds for trusting his veracity, that he is really trying to speak the truth so far as he knows it; his knowledge, that he has had opportunities of knowing the truth about this matter; and his judgment, that he has made proper use of those opportunities in coming to the conclusion which he affirms.
However plain and obvious these reasons may be, so that no man of ordinary intelligence, reflecting upon the matter, could fail to arrive at them, it is nevertheless true that a great many persons do habitually disregard them in weighing testimony. Of the two questions, equally important to the trustworthiness of a witness, "Is he dishonest?" and "May he be mistaken?" the majority of mankind are perfectly satisfied if one can, with some show of probability, be answered in the negative. The excellent moral character of a man is alleged as ground for accepting his statements about things which he cannot possibly have known.

Adopted from Wikiquote. Last update June 3, 2021. History

Help us to complete the source, original and additional information

Do you have more details about the quote "In the first case he is lying, and his moral character is to blame; in the second case he is ignorant or mistaken, and …" by William Kingdon Clifford?
William Kingdon Clifford photo
William Kingdon Clifford 48
English mathematician and philosopher 1845–1879

Related quotes

Richard Whately photo

“He that is not aware of his ignorance, will be only misled by his knowledge.”

Richard Whately (1787–1863) English rhetorician, logician, economist, and theologian

Thoughts and Apophthegms from the Writings of Archbishop Whately (1856), p. 164 http://books.google.com/books?id=kW8YAAAAIAAJ&pg=PA164

Pliny the Younger photo

“His only fault is that he has no fault.”
Nihil peccat, nisi quod nihil peccat.

Pliny the Younger (61–113) Roman writer

Letter 26, 1.
Letters, Book IX

John Stuart Mill photo
Daniel Kahneman photo

“He's taking an inside view. He should forget about his own case and look for what happened in other cases.”

Source: Thinking, Fast and Slow (2011), Chapter 23, "The outside view", page 254 (ISBN 9780141033570).

Charles Bowen photo
John Bartholomew Gough photo
Allan Kardec photo

“Only one who has learned much can fully appreciate his ignorance.
He knows well the limits of his knowledge and how much is waiting to be learned.”

Louis L'Amour (1908–1988) Novelist, short story writer

Source: Education of a Wandering Man (1989), Ch. 11

William Brett, 1st Viscount Esher photo

Related topics