“Some forms of Kantianism put great weight on “what we can imagine” holding that this can be a source of insight into necessary connections. Thus various of Kant’s arguments about space and time depend on the purported fact that it is impossible for us to imagine certain things: we can know, Kant claims, a priori that space has only three dimensions because we cannot imagine it as having more than three dimensions. History in the form of non-Euclidean geometry and modern physics has put paid to that particular line of argument, but in general we should beware of depending too much on “What we can imagine?,” especially in politics. As Nietzsche puts it somewhere, sometimes the fact that you can’t imagine a situation in which things are very different from the way they are now is not an especially good argument for the claim that they must be as they now are, but, rather, represents a failure of your powers about which you should feel mildly apologetic.”

Source: Philosophy and Real Politics (2008), pp. 48-49.

Adopted from Wikiquote. Last update July 14, 2022. History

Help us to complete the source, original and additional information

Do you have more details about the quote "Some forms of Kantianism put great weight on “what we can imagine” holding that this can be a source of insight into ne…" by Raymond Geuss?
Raymond Geuss photo
Raymond Geuss 38
British philosopher 1946

Related quotes

Willem de Sitter photo
Arthur Koestler photo
Hans Reichenbach photo
Jean Metzinger photo
Albert Gleizes photo
Hans Reichenbach photo
Arthur Stanley Eddington photo

“We are saved the difficulty of imagining how the processes of life can go on in two dimensions, because nothing goes on.”

Arthur Stanley Eddington (1882–1944) British astrophysicist

Space, Time and Gravitation (1920)
Context: It is of interest to inquire what happens when the aviator's speed... approximates to the velocity of light. Lengths in the direction of flight become smaller and smaller, until for the speed of light they shrink to zero. The aviator and the objects accompanying him shrink to two dimensions. We are saved the difficulty of imagining how the processes of life can go on in two dimensions, because nothing goes on. Time is arrested altogether. This is the description according to the terrestrial observer. The aviator himself detects nothing unusual; he does not perceive that he has stopped moving. He is merely waiting for the next instant to come before making the next movement; and the mere fact that time is arrested means that he does not perceive that the next instant is a long time coming.<!--p.26

Northrop Frye photo
Hans Reichenbach photo
Arthur Stanley Eddington photo

Related topics