“The Machine Age’s commitment to cause and effect was the source of many dilemmas, including the one involving free will. At the turn of the century the American philosopher E. A. Singer, Jr., showed that science had, in effect, been cheating. It was using two different relationships but calling both cause and effect. He pointed out, for example, that acorns do not cause oaks because they are not sufficient, even though they are necessary, for oaks. An acorn thrown into the ocean, or planted in the desert or an Arctic ice cap does not yield an oak. To call the relationship between an acorn and an oak ‘probabilistic’ or ‘non deterministic causality,’ as many scientists did, was cheating because it is not possible to have a probability other than 1.0 associated with a cause; a cause completely determines its effect. Therefore, Singer chose to call this relationship ‘producer-product’ and to differentiate it from cause-effect.”

Source: 1980s, Creating the Corporate Future, 1981, p. 224-225 as cited in: David Ing (2010) "The producer-product relation, and coproducers in systems theory". in the Coevolving blog, September 02, 2010.

Adopted from Wikiquote. Last update June 3, 2021. History

Help us to complete the source, original and additional information

Do you have more details about the quote "The Machine Age’s commitment to cause and effect was the source of many dilemmas, including the one involving free will…" by Russell L. Ackoff?
Russell L. Ackoff photo
Russell L. Ackoff 70
Scientist 1919–2009

Related quotes

Rollo May photo

“The acorn becomes an oak by means of automatic growth; no commitment is necessary.”

Rollo May (1909–1994) US psychiatrist

Source: The Courage to Create (1975), Ch. 1 : The Courage to Create, p. 21
Context: The acorn becomes an oak by means of automatic growth; no commitment is necessary. The kitten similarly becomes a cat on the basis of instinct. Nature and being are identical in creatures like them. But a man or woman becomes fully human only by his or her choices and his or her commitment to them. People attain worth and dignity by the multitude of decisions they make from day by day. These decisions require courage.

Russell L. Ackoff photo

“You must remember that an oak tree is not a crime against the acorn.”

David Zindell (1952) American writer

Source: War in Heaven (1998), p. 634

Rebecca Solnit photo

“Sometimes, cause and effect are centuries apart”

Rebecca Solnit (1961) Author and essayist from United States
Charles Babbage photo
Swami Vivekananda photo

“The will is not free—it is a phenomenon bound by cause and effect—but there is something behind the will which is free.”

Swami Vivekananda (1863–1902) Indian Hindu monk and phylosopher

Pearls of Wisdom

Max Frisch photo

“Cause and effect are never divided between two people”

Max Frisch (1911–1991) Swiss playwright and novelist

I'm not Stiller (1955)

Marshall McLuhan photo

“Effects are perceived, whereas causes are conceived. Effects always preceed causes in the actual developmental order.”

Marshall McLuhan (1911–1980) Canadian educator, philosopher, and scholar-- a professor of English literature, a literary critic, and a …

Source: 1990s and beyond, The Book of Probes : Marshall McLuhan (2011), p. 303

Related topics